AV Observatory
We publish early and update often. Spot missing information or an error? Or have a suggestion? support@av-observatory.com

Federal Oversight

NHTSA Investigations and Voluntary Recalls

Search NHTSA investigations and safety recalls involving automated driving. Investigations and recalls are separate categories, organized chronologically, with official records and linked cases where available.

Investigations indexed
29
Open / closed investigations
10 / 19
Recall campaigns indexed
69
29 records shown
OpenRecall QueryRQ26006

Waymo · Effectiveness of recall remedy for Waymo AVs passing stopped school buses

On December 10, 2025, Waymo filed recall 25E084 to address the safety risk associated with driving past such stopped school buses.

NHTSA ODI ↗
Opened
Nov 6, 2026
Closed
Still open
Product / system
WAYMO 5TH GENERATION ADS
OpenDefect PetitionDP26010

Tesla · Exceeds posted speed limits in active school zones

NHTSA opened a defect petition review after a petitioner alleged that Tesla Model Y robotaxis and Cybercabs exceed posted speed limits in active school zones while automated driving is engaged. The agency will assess the allegations and supporting video evidence before deciding whether to open a formal defect investigation.

NHTSA ODI ↗
Opened
Oct 9, 2026
Closed
Still open
Product / system
TESLA ROBOTAXI (CYBERCAB)
OpenPreliminary EvaluationPE26007

Other AV / ADAS · Crashes involving comma.ai driving automation products

NHTSA is investigating whether comma.ai's aftermarket driving-assistance system failed to detect stopped or slow vehicles ahead. Five reported crashes involved such vehicles; two crashes caused three deaths, and four crashes injured eleven others. Investigators will examine system engagement, performance, and safeguards.

NHTSA ODI ↗
Opened
Sep 21, 2026
Closed
Still open
Product / system
COMMA.AI COMMA 3X
OpenAudit QueryAQ26003

Avride · Compliance with Standing General Order 2021-01 Reporting Requirements

NHTSA is auditing Avride's crash reports for potential omissions or inaccuracies about injuries and available police reports. Police records suggested possible injuries that some reports did not identify, while other reports later removed injury allegations. The agency is assessing whether earlier incidents remain unreported and submitted information is complete.

NHTSA ODI ↗
Opened
Sep 14, 2026
Closed
Still open
Product / system
AVRIDE AUTOMATED DRIVING SYSTEM
OpenAudit QueryAQ26002

Tesla · Tesla Cybercab federal safety certification audit

NHTSA opened an audit query into Tesla's certification of the Cybercab, which lacks conventional steering, braking, and accelerator controls. Investigators are examining the technical basis for Tesla's claim that the vehicle complies with federal motor vehicle safety standards, including whether Tesla considered certain standards inapplicable.

NHTSA ↗
Opened
Sep 3, 2026
Closed
Still open
Product / system
2026 Tesla Robotaxi (Cybercab)
OpenPreliminary EvaluationPE26003

Avride · Automated Driving System (ADS) conflict avoidance, driving behavior competence and assertiveness

NHTSA is investigating crashes involving Avride vehicles in Dallas and Austin, including unsafe lane changes, failures to slow for vehicles ahead, and impacts with partially obstructing objects. The vehicles were operating autonomously under in-vehicle supervision; the reported incidents caused property damage and one alleged minor injury.

NHTSA ODI ↗
Opened
May 6, 2026
Closed
Still open
Product / system
AVRIDE AUTOMATED DRIVING SYSTEM
OpenEngineering AnalysisEA26002

Tesla · FSD collisions in reduced roadway visibility

NHTSA upgraded its probe of Tesla Full Self-Driving in poor visibility to an engineering analysis covering about 3.2 million vehicles, citing nine crashes, one fatal, in glare and airborne obscurants. It will assess whether the system's degradation-detection feature recognizes reduced camera visibility and alerts drivers in time, including Tesla's later software update.

ODI opening resume ↗
Opened
Mar 18, 2026
Closed
Still open
Product / system
Tesla vehicles with FSD
OpenPreliminary EvaluationPE26001

Waymo · Child pedestrian struck near elementary school

NHTSA opened a preliminary evaluation after a driverless Waymo vehicle struck a child who ran from behind a double-parked SUV near a Santa Monica elementary school during drop-off on January 23, 2026; the child had minor injuries. NHTSA will examine whether the system showed appropriate caution, its school-zone behavior and speed-limit adherence, and its response after impact.

ODI opening resume ↗
Opened
Jan 29, 2026
Closed
Still open
Product / system
Waymo 5th Generation ADS
ClosedPreliminary EvaluationPE25013

Waymo · Passing stopped school buses

NHTSA opened a preliminary evaluation after a driverless Waymo passed a stopped school bus in Atlanta with its red lights flashing and stop arm extended, near students getting off. Investigators are examining how Waymo's automated driving system responds to stopped school buses and complies with school-bus safety laws.

ODI opening resume ↗
Opened
Oct 17, 2025
Closed
Nov 6, 2026
Product / system
Waymo 5th Generation ADS
OpenPreliminary EvaluationPE25012

Tesla · Traffic-safety violations with FSD engaged

NHTSA opened a preliminary evaluation covering about 2.9 million Tesla vehicles with Full Self-Driving (Supervised or Beta) after complaints, crash reports and media reports alleging red-light running and entry into opposing lanes, including crashes with injuries. NHTSA will assess whether drivers received enough warning and time to supervise and intervene.

ODI opening resume ↗
Opened
Oct 7, 2025
Closed
Still open
Product / system
Tesla vehicles equipped with FSD (Supervised) or FSD (Beta)
ClosedPreliminary EvaluationPE24033

Tesla · Actually Smart Summon sessions resulting in low-speed impacts.

NHTSA reviewed crashes during Tesla's phone-controlled Actually Smart Summon parking maneuvers. Most involved minor property damage, including impacts with parked vehicles, gates, or bollards; two involved snow-obscured cameras. The agency closed the evaluation in April 2026 after software updates, citing low incident frequency and severity.

NHTSA ODI ↗
Opened
Jan 6, 2025
Closed
Apr 3, 2026
Product / system
TESLA MODEL 3
ClosedPreliminary EvaluationPE24031

Tesla · FSD Collisions in Reduced Roadway Visibility Conditions

NHTSA examined whether Tesla Full Self-Driving appropriately detected and responded to reduced roadway visibility, including glare and other camera-obscuring conditions, following four reported crashes. The agency upgraded the investigation to an engineering analysis in March 2026 to examine system degradation detection, driver alerts, and software changes.

NHTSA ODI ↗
Opened
Oct 17, 2024
Closed
Mar 18, 2026
Product / system
TESLA CYBERTRUCK
ClosedPreliminary EvaluationPE24016

Waymo · Unexpected ADS behavior

NHTSA opened a preliminary evaluation of Waymo's fifth-generation driving system after 22 incidents, 17 of them crashes without injuries, in which vehicles struck gates, chains or parked cars, or appeared to disobey traffic control devices. It will evaluate how the system detects and responds to traffic controls and avoids stationary objects, across about 444 vehicles.

ODI opening resume ↗
Opened
May 13, 2024
Closed
Jul 22, 2025
Product / system
Waymo 5th Generation ADS
ClosedPreliminary EvaluationPE24015

Zoox · Unexpected ADS braking

NHTSA opened an investigation after two Zoox vehicles unexpectedly braked in autonomous mode and were rear-ended by motorcyclists, causing minor injuries. Investigators are assessing the automated driving system's braking behavior, including near crosswalks and vulnerable road users.

ODI information request ↗
Opened
May 10, 2024
Closed
Mar 31, 2025
Product / system
Zoox ADS-equipped passenger vehicles
OpenRecall QueryRQ24009

Tesla · Recall 23V838 Remedy Effectiveness

NHTSA is assessing whether Tesla's 2023 Autopilot recall adequately addressed driver misuse risks. The agency cited post-remedy crashes, preliminary testing concerns, and features of the remedy that drivers could opt into or reverse. Investigators are also examining why other software updates were not included in the recall.

NHTSA ODI ↗
Opened
Apr 25, 2024
Closed
Still open
Product / system
TESLA CYBERTRUCK
ClosedPreliminary EvaluationPE23018

Cruise · ADS behavior around pedestrians

NHTSA examined whether Cruise's driverless vehicles exercised appropriate caution around pedestrians, reviewing five pedestrian collisions, three involving injuries.

ODI closing resume ↗
Opened
Oct 16, 2023
Closed
Jan 14, 2025
Product / system
Cruise ADS-equipped vehicles
ClosedAudit QueryAQ23001

Zoox · Purpose-built vehicle certification

NHTSA's audit query examined whether Zoox properly self-certified its purpose-built, control-free vehicle as compliant with federal safety standards; a December 2024 inspection report found multiple apparent noncompliances. It closed August 4, 2025 after NHTSA granted Zoox a conditional demonstration exemption that requires it to remove claims of full compliance.

ODI closing resume ↗
Opened
Mar 3, 2023
Closed
Aug 4, 2025
Product / system
Zoox purpose-built vehicles
ClosedPreliminary EvaluationPE22014

Cruise · Hard braking and immobilizations

NHTSA's preliminary evaluation reviewed 7,632 hard-braking events and vehicle immobilizations by Cruise's driverless vehicles, which contributed to 10 reported crashes, four injuring vulnerable road users; no immobilization caused a crash or injury. It closed August 20, 2024 after Cruise's recall 24E-067 and software updates to reduce unexpected braking.

ODI closing resume ↗
Opened
Dec 12, 2022
Closed
Aug 20, 2024
Product / system
Cruise ADS
ClosedEngineering AnalysisEA22002

Tesla · Autopilot driver engagement and misuse

NHTSA's engineering analysis of about 2.0 million Tesla vehicles found that Autopilot's weak driver-engagement controls, paired with high control authority, led to foreseeable misuse and avoidable crashes, including at least 13 fatal ones. It closed April 25, 2024 after Tesla's recall 23V-838; NHTSA then opened recall query RQ24009 to assess whether the remedy is effective.

ODI closing resume ↗
Opened
Jun 8, 2022
Closed
Apr 25, 2024
Product / system
Tesla vehicles equipped with Autopilot
ClosedRecall QueryRQ22001

Pony.ai · Recall 22E-016

NHTSA reviewed Pony.ai's 2022 recall after a software error shut down a driverless vehicle's automated driving system and contributed to an October 2021 crash. It closed the query in October 2023 after finding the identified vehicles and software fix adequate, while retaining authority to reopen the matter.

NHTSA ODI ↗
Opened
Apr 10, 2022
Closed
Oct 30, 2023
Product / system
PONY.AI AUTOMATED DRIVING SYSTEM
ClosedAudit QueryAQ22001

Pony.ai · NHTSA SGO 2021-01 Reporting Requirements

NHTSA audited whether Pony.ai promptly and accurately reported an October 2021 driverless crash under federal crash-reporting requirements. After reviewing the company's subsequent reports and corrective procedures, the agency closed the audit in January 2025 without making a formal finding of compliance.

NHTSA ODI ↗
Opened
Mar 24, 2022
Closed
Jan 16, 2025
Product / system
PONY.AI AUTOMATED DRIVING SYSTEM
ClosedPreliminary EvaluationPE22002

Tesla · Unexpected Brake Activation

NHTSA investigated reports of unexpected deceleration in 2021–2022 Tesla Model 3 and Model Y vehicles using adaptive cruise control, Autopilot, or Full Self-Driving. Drivers described sudden braking at highway speeds without obstacles ahead. The agency closed the evaluation in June 2026 after complaints declined and no related collisions were identified.

NHTSA ODI ↗
Opened
Feb 16, 2022
Closed
Jun 29, 2026
Product / system
TESLA MODEL 3
ClosedPreliminary EvaluationPE21020

Tesla · Autopilot & First Responder Scenes

NHTSA investigated crashes in which Tesla vehicles using Autopilot struck stationary emergency-response vehicles at existing crash scenes. The evaluation also examined driver-monitoring safeguards and Autopilot's operating limitations. In June 2022, NHTSA upgraded the case to an engineering analysis for further crash and human-factors investigation.

NHTSA ODI ↗
Opened
Aug 13, 2021
Closed
Jun 8, 2022
Product / system
TESLA MODEL 3
ClosedEngineering AnalysisEA20003

Tesla · Loss of rearview camera

NHTSA investigated Tesla media-control-unit failures that could disable the rearview camera in certain Model S and Model X vehicles. Investigators linked the failures to wear in onboard flash memory with an estimated service life of five to six years, substantially shorter than expected vehicle life.

NHTSA ODI ↗
Opened
Nov 12, 2020
Closed
May 2, 2024
Product / system
TESLA MODEL S
ClosedPreliminary EvaluationPE20010

Tesla · Loss of rearview camera

NHTSA examined reports that worn flash memory in Tesla Model S media-control units could disable the rearview camera. Tesla supplied thousands of complaints and warranty claims, and investigators found elevated failure rates in some production groups. The inquiry was upgraded to an engineering analysis in November 2020.

NHTSA ODI ↗
Opened
Jun 22, 2020
Closed
Nov 22, 2020
Product / system
TESLA MODEL S
ClosedPreliminary EvaluationPE16007

Tesla · Automatic vehicle control systems

NHTSA investigated Tesla Autopilot following a fatal 2016 collision with a crossing tractor-trailer in Florida. It assessed automatic braking, driver engagement, and system design, and closed the evaluation in January 2017 without identifying a safety-related defect trend.

NHTSA ODI ↗
Opened
Jun 28, 2016
Closed
Jan 19, 2017
Product / system
TESLA MODEL S
ClosedPreliminary EvaluationPE14010

Other AV / ADAS · Active Safety System Malfunction

NHTSA reviewed two Chevrolet Impala rear-end crashes initially attributed to unintended automatic braking. Investigators found evidence consistent with inadvertent electronic parking-brake activation rather than a failure of forward-collision automation. A separate parking-brake software defect prompted recall 14V-541; the evaluation closed in November 2014.

NHTSA ODI ↗
Opened
Apr 15, 2014
Closed
Nov 21, 2014
Product / system
CHEVROLET IMPALA
Associated NHTSA recall:
ClosedPreliminary EvaluationPE13024

Other AV / ADAS · Inappropriate autonomous braking

NHTSA investigated unexpected braking in 2007–2008 Honda Odyssey vehicles linked to a Vehicle Stability Assist sensor and calibration problem. Honda recalled approximately 344,000 vehicles to address the condition, which could apply strong braking without illuminating brake lamps. The investigation closed in November 2013.

NHTSA ODI ↗
Opened
Jun 25, 2013
Closed
Nov 4, 2013
Product / system
HONDA ODYSSEY
Associated NHTSA recall:
ClosedPreliminary EvaluationPE12022

Other AV / ADAS · Collision Mitigation System Malfunction

NHTSA investigated two reports of unintended Intelligent Brake Assist activation in 2013 Infiniti JX35 vehicles. Investigators reproduced brief unnecessary braking under unusual road conditions; Nissan introduced a software update through a service campaign. NHTSA closed the evaluation after determining the remaining safety risk was low.

NHTSA ODI ↗
Opened
Jul 26, 2012
Closed
Nov 29, 2012
Product / system
INFINITI JX35

Sources: NHTSA ODI investigations and NHTSA recall campaign records. Investigations and recalls are different regulatory actions; an open case is not a finding of a defect. Investigation dates and statuses are taken from NHTSA opening and closing records. Recall remedies are not equivalent to an investigation being closed. Cases are connected only where NHTSA identifies an associated campaign. Investigation feed: site snapshot · 2026-11-16. Recall feed: 2026-11-16. Primary-source NHTSA post-2010 recall campaigns, deduplicated across model rows.